Performed Leonard Bernstein’s Partner Learn He had been Gay?

Performed Leonard Bernstein’s Partner Learn He had been Gay?

Songs is actually Bernstein’s best and more than lingering interests. However, his love existence was a significant part out of his generate-right up, with his characters help us setting a fuller picture of an emotional life which had been full of twists and you may transforms – neatly contribution: “Clearly, he was more comfortable with getting sexual in many different implies and yet he wished a traditional existence, that have a partner and you can youngsters so you’re able to just who he had been devoted. He was an intricate, state-of-the-art man, and you will advanced men and women have cutting-edge individual lifestyle.” step one Interesting once the letters are from men lГ¶ydГ¤ tГ¤mГ¤ and women (usually guys) that have who Bernstein had dating when you look at the 1940s, I’ve chosen rather to target Bernstein’s individual thinking so you’re able to their sexuality, and its particular implications to possess his industry. For the correspondence which have Copland and David Oppenheim particularly, plus in certain emails so you can his cousin Shirley in order to Diamond, he explores his sexual label, often discussing a state out-of dilemma and inner disagreement. Towards the one hand, their record inculcated old-fashioned thinking and you may relationships – ultimately wedding; on the other, their preferences from the 1940s have been always for men. Immediately after his college or university studies was more than, the guy began a process regarding self-exploration on the psychoanalyst he known as “Frau” – Marketa Morris. As we are able to see off their characters, the guy common a comparable specialist having Oppenheim (that have just who Bernstein got a near, undoubtedly personal dating during the early 1940s; their relationship try lifelong).

Shortly after a shaky initiate (due mainly to Bernstein’s 1st tendency to respect marriage due to the fact a beneficial types of try out), the connection off Leonard and Felicia blossomed – including after Jamie, the original of the people, grew up in 1952

It’s no surprise that Bernstein stayed hushed about his sexuality inside emails in order to Koussevitzky – up to, that is, the guy happily revealed his first involvement so you can Felicia in December 1946, recommending a picture of his sexuality which had been at best unfinished. Bernstein himself try anxious that their sex lives may have a good damaging impact on their employment prospects, dreading he could have difficulty shopping for a career while the a good conductor if this turned into identified that he is actually gay.

It’s worthy of pausing for a moment to consider the brand new cultural and you may societal context one gave Bernstein eg anxiety about how others you will take a look at their sexuality. Of a lot American psychoanalysts on the 1930s and you may 1940s believed homosexuality so you’re able to getting a mental disease that could respond to “treatment”. The research of the Alfred Kinsey while some penned inside the 1948 due to the fact Sexual Behavior about Individual Men (the first “Kinsey Report”) tried to codify quantities of homosexual, heterosexual, and you may asexual behavior into the dudes to your “Kinsey Level”, looking to demonstrate that guys didn’t go with clean and private groups. dos

There can be an effective predictably unlawful a reaction to Kinsey’s findings: as well as others, J. Edgar Vacuum, director of the FBI, are small to denounce the new conclusions on profiles out-of Reader’s Digest: “People’s sense of decency announces what is actually normal and what is perhaps not. If the American anybody, younger otherwise dated, arrived at believe that there is absolutely no such as for example procedure while the best otherwise completely wrong, normal otherwise unpredictable, people who create damage civilization will applaud a major profit more the lifestyle.” step 3 Put another way, homosexuality, particularly communism, was “Un-American”. Two years later, into the ed Senate Committee on Costs on Government Departments approved a writeup on brand new “A career out-of Homosexuals or other Sex Perverts when you look at the Government,” coming to hair-elevating end that “homosexuals or other sex perverts are not best persons becoming employed in Bodies for two factors; first, they are usually the wrong, and you can 2nd, it comprise security risks.” 4

Bernstein wasn’t, without a doubt, trying a position about bodies, however, the guy craved acceptance. There can be nothing solid facts to indicate you to conductors weren’t designated to particular positions for their homosexuality on the 1940s and 1950s, even though Dimitri Mitropoulos appear to experienced he had been victimized. But a few of the most highly regarded data on arts was indeed homosexuals, perhaps not minimum Aaron Copland, who had, of the mid-1940s, become the most well known and you will unique sound during the American ancient musical. Bernstein, yet not, aspired to be the music manager off a primary Western band and you will believed– correctly or improperly – that he needed to demonstrate he was a conventional, old-fashioned loved ones guy. Despite Bernstein’s constant protestations that he craved the greater number of individual existence off a composer (where his sexuality would not have become an issue), he might never let go out-of conducting since a significant part off their field.

What the guy failed to need to worry about as often was the newest you can easily effect their sexuality might have for the his relationships – at the very least a lot less much due to the fact their picked partner, Felicia Montealegre, is alarmed. She realized what she is actually committing by herself to help you: just after they partnered, she typed: “you are a good homosexual and you can willing to deal with your as you try, without getting good martyr or compromising me towards the L.B. altar (Letter 320).”

An exceptionally bright child, it’s clear out of Bernstein’s characters house how much cash the guy loved her. An equivalent love stands out because of when you look at the Bernstein’s comments on the all his children (Jamie, Alexander, and you may Nina); and his awesome pure dedication so you’re able to Felicia is actually noticeable in many letters regarding the early 1950s up until the middle-1970s. It absolutely was a relationship which had the rugged times, however, only with new drama off 1976 in addition to their “demo breakup” did it jeopardize to-fall apart. At the end of his lifestyle, Bernstein joked to help you Jonathan Cott one “need love, and that’s why I have 10 thousand romantic household members that is unjust on them because I can’t render any of them everything”. 5 But also for a-quarter off a century, Felicia try brand new exemption: she try undoubtedly the most effective passion for his lifestyle.

1. Dougary, Ginny (2010): “Leonard Bernstein: Magnetic, Pompous – and you may a good Father,” The occasions (London), thirteen March. On the web version from the , accessed .

Martin (1948): Sexual Conclusion throughout the Person Men

4. This report is actually reprinted for the Foster, Thomas An excellent., ed. (2013): Documenting Intimate Things: Prierica. Chicago: College or university off Chi town Drive, pp. 144–eight. Centered on an editorial notice (p. 144): “Much more homosexuals than simply communists was in fact discharged from federal services in this several months [the fresh new 1950s].”

In the Leonard Bernstein Characters because of the Leonard Bernstein, modified because of the Nigel Simeone. Written by Yale School Push during the 2014. Reproduced which have consent.

Nigel Simeone is famous because an author and you can presenter to the songs and is the author of a lot courses and Leonard Bernstein: Western Front side Story. The guy resides in Northamptonshire, Uk.




Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *